With the recent news involving Michael Jackson’s children becoming the subjects of a guardianship, many people are asking questions about this function of the law, and its meaning and application in connection with their older friends and relatives who are residents of Florida.

It is well known and recognized that Florida is home to a large population of older people who have outlived outlived all those who care for them.  Sometimes, because these persons are vulnerable and susceptible to exploitation,  it becomes necessary to seek the protection of the court’s system of guardianship.   Often, I encounter situations where there are individuals who, although they still have relatives and friends who want to manage their finances, their friends and relatives may be fighting among themselves, or may be financially or emotionally exploiting the individual.  These situations also present circumstances that may warrant a court’s examination of what may be in the older person’s best interest. (more…)

Fifth District Court of Appeals Encourages Legislature to Clarify Statute

The decision of whether and when to petition for incapacity of an elderly relative is challenging and can rarely be accomplished without the assistance of an experienced practitioner. However, even with an experienced attorney the frustration level is high for parties involved in the guardianship process, due in part to the lack of clarity and direction contained in the relevant portions of the law.

The procedure for asking a Florida court to declare someone incapacitated is codified in Florida Statute §744.331(4) which explains the process following the petition to determine incapacity:

“Within 5 days after a petition for determination of incapacity has been filed, the court shall appoint an examining committee consisting of three members. One member must be a psychiatrist or other physician. The remaining members must be either a psychologist, gerontologist, another psychiatrist, or other physician, a registered nurse, nurse practitioner, licensed social worker, a person with an advanced degree in gerontology from an accredited institution of higher education, or other person who by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may, in the court’s discretion, advise the court in the form of an expert opinion[.]” (more…)

Third District Upholds Palm Beach Probate Court’s Appointment of Guardian Not Related to the Ward by Blood or Marriage.

The decision of whether and when to have a loved one declared incompetent is a difficult and challenging process, and should involve an attorney who is familiar with the issues and procedures of guardianship law. In Florida, the guardianship statutes provide for certain procedures to protect the rights of the person who is allegedly incompetent.

The process generally involves the filing of a Petition to Determine Incapacity. Fla.Stat. §744.331(1). Thereafter, the Court will appoint an examining committee to assess the mental and physical condition of the person who is allegedly incapacitated. Fla.Stat. §744.331(4). Depending on the report presented to the Court, a hearing will be conducted wherein testimony and other evidence is heard, and the Court decides if the alleged incapacitated person is actually incapacitated and then whether a guardian is necessary. (more…)

When is a Guardian barred from suing the doctors that allegedly caused her daughter’s brain damage?

Mrs. Thomas was named as plenary guardian for her daughter, Tammy, after Tammy suffered a heart attack and brain damage while giving birth to her baby.  Mrs. Thomas claims that Tammy wouldn’t have been hurt, except for the doctor taking too long to deal with Tammy’s high blood pressure.  On Tammy’s behalf, and she sued the doctor, the hospital, and others.

The trial court ruled that Mrs. Thomas took too long to bring the lawsuit, and it was barred as a matter of law by the Florida Medical Malpractice Statute of Limitations.  Under that Florida law, Mrs. Thomas has two (2) years to file suit.  Calculating  that deadline is key: on what date does time begin to run for the plenary guardian? (more…)